Baseball Cards For Sale Craigslist (2024)

FAQs

How can I find out how much my baseball cards are worth? ›

To find the value of sports cards, there is no better source than eBay. eBay will show you exactly what a particular card in a variety of conditions has recently sold for.

The most popular way to sell baseball cards locally is to use pawn shops or local antique shops. Alternatively, you can list your collection on local selling marketplaces like Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist. Local sales are ideal since you can get paid in cash and avoid shipping and online payment processing fees.

CollX uses millions of historical auction prices to calculate a card's average value. As you add cards to your collection, you'll see your overall portfolio value grow. As your cards rise or fall in value, CollX helps you track both individual card values and your overall portfolio value.

This is why selling and buying sports cards is challenging but also fun. For example, the best time to sell NFL football cards is during the months of September through January the next year. Then, best time to sell your MLB cards would be starting with April and up to October.

Ask your local card shop: Many collectible card and memorabilia shops provide appraisal services, so your favorite spot should be your first stop. Even if they can't appraise your collection themselves, they may be able to point you towards other appraisal businesses in the area.

Baseball card values can vary significantly, with some cards worth just a few cents, while others, like the ones on this list, reach multimillion-dollar price tags.

1. 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle #311. A 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle retook its spot as the most valuable piece of sports memorabilia in history when another example of the “Rosen Find” sold on 22 August 2022 for $12.6 million.

If you're selling ungraded sports cards, general marketplaces like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, and OfferUp are some of your best options. You can also see if any card shops are willing to buy your ungraded cards in bulk if you want a fast sale.

If you collect baseball cards, organize your collection by team, then year, then player, or whatever way you think is best. There really is no wrong answer. Just make sure you come up with a system that works for you and you are consistent.

Ludex is the fastest and most accurate sports and trading card scanner app. Take a picture, identify, and get card values instantly. Download For Free!

Is there an app to sell baseball cards? ›

Alt is hands-down, the best sports card app and marketplace on the Internet.

The four conditions used for grading are the quality of the surface, sharpness of corners, crispness and sharpness of edges and how well the image on the card itself is centered, front and back. Not every card is a candidate for grading. Newer cards have higher standards for grading.

Head to PSAcard.com/auctionprices and search for your card. The more refined the query, the more accurate the results. It is best to include the year, manufacturer and subject of your card in your search. If you include the card number, expect All-Star results.

Selling the card UNGRADED is the safest move unless you're ABSOLUTELY certain that you'll garner a NM-MT or better grade. However, PSA 9 and PSA 10 examples are why so many people clamor to grade this card.

Sometimes CollX's visual search doesn't correctly match a card, but it is up to you as a seller to verify that the card details are correct, and the listing is accurate. We don't automatically determine the condition, so this is also something you need to verify as the seller.

How to Value Your Cards. To get a value that will get collectors to check out what you have, you'll want your collection scored by a grading company. They rate cards on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the best condition, according to Kiplinger. Treat grading companies like doctors.

CollX | Cards or Cash using the CollX App! Free to download for collectors!